What Is the Fate of Unused IVF Embryos?

By BSc, MSc, PhD (senior clinical embryologist), MD, PhD (gynecologist), BSc, MSc (embryologist), BSc, MSc (embryologist) and (embryologist).
Last Update: 10/08/2021

In most in vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles, either with your own eggs or with egg donation, there are embryos left over at the end of the treatment. This is due to the improvement of assisted reproduction techniques and the tendency to transfer a single embryo to the patient's uterus.

The embryos left over from an assisted reproduction treatment, if they are of good quality, are vitrified to preserve them. The destiny of these frozen embryos depends both on the legislation that regulates assisted reproduction techniques in Spain (Law 14/2006) and on the decision of the couple or patient.

What is the origin of the surplus embryos?

When a couple undergoes in vitro fertilization (IVF) reproductive treatment, either conventional IVF or intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), the aim is to obtain as many good quality embryos as possible. The aim of this is to increase the chances of success of the cycle.

However, it is not possible to transfer all the embryos obtained in the cycle to the patient's uterus in a single attempt. The main reasons are these two:

  • The Spanish law on assisted human reproduction techniques (Law 14/2006) allows the transfer of a maximum of 3 embryos.
  • The intention to avoid multiple pregnancy. In this way, a single embryo will be transferred whenever possible, i.e. without compromising the chances of success.

It should be noted that the optimization of embryo freezing techniques that has taken place in recent years makes it possible to cryopreserve supernumerary embryos without compromising their survival rates. In addition, the quality of the treatments and embryo selection techniques has also increased.

Considering undergoing a fertility treatment? By getting your individual Fertility Report your will see different clinics especially selected for you out of the pool of clinics that meet our strict quality criteria. Moreover, it will offer you a comparison between the fees and conditions each clinic offers in order for you to make a well informed choice.

All these advances allow more single embryo transfers to be performed without decreasing the pregnancy rates per ovarian stimulation cycle. However, these improvements in turn lead to an increasing number of surplus embryos.

How many embryos to transfer?

The couple or single woman who undergoes the reproductive treatment is the one who decides, together with the medical recommendations of the specialists, the number of embryos to be transferred. Currently, it is most common to transfer one or two embryos per transfer.

Only in cases with poor prognosis three embryos are transferred. In this aspect, it is important that specialists inform about the advantages, risks and effects of transferring one, two or three embryos depending on the characteristics of the woman and the specific medical situation.

Fate of frozen human embryos

The choice of the number of embryos to transfer is not the last important decision to be made. After the embryo transfer, a decision must be made about what to do with the untransferred embryos.

In Spain, the cryopreservation of embryos is regulated by article 11 of Law 14/2006. Among other things, this article states:

Pre-embryos left over from the application of in vitro fertilization techniques that are not transferred to the woman in a reproductive cycle may be cryopreserved in banks authorized for this purpose.

Law 14/2006 also specifies the options regarding the destination of frozen supernumerary embryos:

  • Own use, either because the first attempt has failed or because a second child is desired. This option allows another embryo transfer without the need to undergo ovarian stimulation or follicular puncture. In this way, the most annoying stages of IVF treatments are avoided.
  • Donation for reproductive purposes. Patients, in this case, must meet the same requirements stipulated for donors. The recipient couple will perform what is known as an embryo adoption.
  • Donation for research purposes. The couple will be informed of the specific project for which their embryos will be used and must sign a specific consent form stating the project in question.
  • Cessation of its conservation without any other use.

This last option can only be used when the medical authorities consider that the woman no longer meets the appropriate requirements for the assisted reproductive technique. Furthermore, as stipulated by law, this must be decided by specialists outside the centre where the embryos are kept.

Once the centre has explained in detail the four possible alternatives to the woman or couple, the woman or couple must sign an informed consent form authorising the destination chosen. This consent is signed prior to IVF treatment, but must be renewed (or modified to give another destination to the embryos) at least every two years.

It is common that the first destination chosen is cryopreservation for later use by the woman or couple, either because of failure of the first IVF cycle or because they want to give a sibling to the child already born. However, after several years, the couple or woman may decide to change the fate of the cryopreserved embryos.

The donation of pre-embryos for adoption by other couples is often an option that is rarely chosen. In addition, the requirement that the woman must not be over 35 years of age to be able to donate is an impediment, since most patients who undergo IVF are over this age.

On the other hand, donation for research purposes is also not very popular. The truth is that, at present, many couples do not care for their embryos and do not respond to the renewal or modification of the consent.

What happens with the abandoned embryos in Spain?

One of the problems that assisted reproduction clinics currently suffer is that many patients with frozen embryos do not renew their consent. This means that they do not communicate that they wish to continue with the maintenance of these cryopreserved embryos nor do they indicate a new destination.

If, after two consecutive renewals, the centre where the embryos are stored does not manage to obtain the signature of consent from the woman or couple, and is able to demonstrate the actions carried out to obtain the renewal without obtaining a response, the embryos will remain at the disposal of the clinic.

Therefore, in this case, the clinic will be able to choose the destination of the abandoned embryos as long as it maintains the conditions of confidentiality and anonymity and free of charge.

Interview with Dr. Miguel Dolz:

The medical director of the IVF Valencia clinic, Dr. Miguel Dolz, explains in the following interview all the details about the embryos that are left over in IVF, their characteristics and possible destinations.

FAQs from users

What are abandoned embryos from IVF treatment?

By Patricia Recuerda Tomás BSc, MSc (embryologist).

In Assisted Reproduction clinics, when IVF treatment is performed, a number of embryos is obtained that may be more than the number of embryos that the woman or couple needs to have the number of children they want. These embryos are kept cryopreserved in the banks of the clinics until the patients decide what fate they want to give them, since they will not need them.

It may happen that a woman or couple does not want to maintain their embryos, ignoring the requirements of renewal of the destination that the clinic must make at least every 2 years (the woman or the progenitor couple is asked to renew or modify the signed consent). In this case we would be talking about abandoned embryos.

The solution that the law established to dispose of these embryos is that, if during two consecutive renewals it is impossible to obtain the signature of the corresponding consent from the woman or the progenitor couple, and the actions carried out with the aim of obtaining said renewal without obtaining the required response can be demonstrated in a reliable manner, the embryos will remain at the disposal of the clinic, the embryos shall remain at the disposal of the centres in which they are cryopreserved, which may use them according to their criteria for any of the purposes established by Law 14/2006, of 26th May, on assisted human reproduction techniques, maintaining the established requirements of confidentiality and anonymity, as well as being free of charge and non-profit-making.

Can I know which woman or couple my embryos go to if I donate them to other patients?

By José Luis de Pablo BSc, MSc, PhD (senior clinical embryologist).

One of the possibilities within the Informed Consent is to donate your embryos to another patient/s for reproductive purposes. These embryos become part of the Centre's own embryo bank. The donation of embryos will be made by the Centre to the recipient patient/couple, who will be reminded of the free, secret and anonymous nature of embryo donation and its nature as a voluntary, altruistic and disinterested act. Likewise, in your case, you will not be able to know to whom the embryos have been donated.

If artificial insemination is performed instead of in vitro fertilisation, are there also supernumerary embryos?

By Rebeca Reus BSc, MSc (embryologist).

No. In assisted reproduction treatments in which artificial insemination is performed, fertilisation takes place in the woman's uterus. Therefore, neither eggs are extracted nor embryos are generated in the laboratory.

Are better results achieved with a second IVF than with the transfer of frozen embryos?

By Rebeca Reus BSc, MSc (embryologist).

One of the factors that most influences the results of in vitro fertilisation (IVF) treatments is the quality of the embryos.

Thanks to advances in cryopreservation, we can now vitrify (freeze) embryos without altering their quality.

Therefore, if the embryos are of good quality, the results of vitrified embryo transfer (VET) are practically the same as if we transfer fresh embryos from a second ovarian stimulation.

However, it must be considered that it is much more comfortable for the patient to transfer frozen embryos than to have to undergo ovarian stimulation and follicular puncture again. For this reason, it is most common to transfer all the cryopreserved embryos before starting another ovarian stimulation cycle.

Suggested for you

If you want to know more details about Law, we recommend you to read the following article: Egg Donation & UK Law - What Does the HFE Act 2008 Say?

On the other hand, if you wish to know what the transfer of frozen embryos consists of, you can find more information here: How Does the Frozen Embryo Transfer (FET) Procedure Work?

Our editors have made great efforts to create this content for you. By sharing this post, you are helping us to keep ourselves motivated to work even harder.

References

Berrocal Lanzarot, A. I. (2007). Análisis de la nueva Ley 14/2006, de 26 de mayo sobre técnicas de reproducción humana asistida. Una primera aproximación a su contenido. Revista de la Escuela de Medicina Legal de la U.C.M.

Comisión Nacional de Reproducción Humana Asistida (CNRHA) (2015). Aspectos legales y éticos de la donación. En: Registro Nacional de Donantes de Gametos y Preembriones. Ministerio de Sanidad, Consumo y Bienestar Social de España.

Ley 14/2006, de 26 de mayo, sobre técnicas de reproducción humana asistida. Jefatura del Estado «BOE» núm. 126, de 27 de mayo de 2006 Referencia: BOE-A-2006-9292. (ver)

FAQs from users: 'What are abandoned embryos from IVF treatment?', 'Can I know which woman or couple my embryos go to if I donate them to other patients?', 'If artificial insemination is performed instead of in vitro fertilisation, are there also supernumerary embryos?' and 'Are better results achieved with a second IVF than with the transfer of frozen embryos?'.

Read more

Authors and contributors

 José Luis de Pablo
José Luis de Pablo
BSc, MSc, PhD
Senior Clinical Embryologist
Double Degree in Biology and Biochemistry from the University of Navarra. Master’s Degree about the Theoretical Basis and Laboratory Procedures in Assisted Reproduction from the University of Valencia (UV). Senior Clinical Embryologist from the ESHRE and ASEBIR Certification in Clinical Embryology. More than 15 years of experience as the director of IVF labs. More information about José Luis de Pablo
 Miguel Dolz Arroyo
Miguel Dolz Arroyo
MD, PhD
Gynecologist
Bachelor's Degree in Medicine and Surgery from the Medicine Faculty of the University of Valencia (UV) and Doctor in Medicine, finished in 1988 and 1995, respectively. Physician specialized in Obstetrics & Gynecology. Expert in Reproductive Medicine, with more than 20 years' experience in the field. He is the Medical Director and founder of FIV Valencia. More information about Miguel Dolz Arroyo
License: 464614458
 Patricia Recuerda Tomás
Patricia Recuerda Tomás
BSc, MSc
Embryologist
Bachelor's Degree in Biology from the University of Alcalá de Henares. Master’s Degree about the Theoretical Basis and Laboratory Procedures in Assisted Reproduction from the University of Valencia (UV). Extensive experience working at several Assisted Reproduction laboratories. More information about Patricia Recuerda Tomás
License: 19882M
 Rebeca Reus
Rebeca Reus
BSc, MSc
Embryologist
Degree in Human Biology (Biochemistry) from the Pompeu Fabra University (UPF). Official Master's Degree in Clinical Analysis Laboratory from the UPF and Master’s Degree about the Theoretical Basis and Laboratory Procedures in Assisted Reproduction from the University of Valencia (UV). More information about Rebeca Reus
 Silvia Azaña Gutiérrez
Silvia Azaña Gutiérrez
Embryologist
Graduate in Health Biology from the University of Alcalá and specialized in Clinical Genetics from the same university. Master in Assisted Reproduction by the University of Valencia in collaboration with IVI clinics. More information about Silvia Azaña Gutiérrez
License: 3435-CV

Find the latest news on assisted reproduction in our channels.